The plan journal

Open Access

Image associated with the article: Resilient Urban Ecologies: Adaptive Sustainable Infrastructures for Addis Ababa
Article Open Access

Resilient Urban Ecologies: Adaptive Sustainable Infrastructures for Addis Ababa

by Ruben Garcia Rubio, Taylor J. Scott pp. 473–494
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia’s capital city, is currently experiencing an unprecedented population boom and subsequent rapid urbanization which has fostered internal imbalances within the city’s urban landscape. To this should be added the negative effects derived from the continued impacts of a changing global climate. Together, these combined consequences have compromised the sustainable development of Addis Ababa. This essay addresses the initial outcomes of the “Addis Ababa River City” research project, an academic program created to address these aforementioned challenges through a holistic urban resilience strategy and design methodology. To do this, the research project proposes the use of a sustainable infrastructure as the primary design intervention, where the existing ecological elements serve as the foundational backbone but also include other urban dimensions. This paper will elaborate on the design methodology and resulting sustainable infrastructure intervention in two different and nested scales, the upper region of the Kebena river and Peacock Park. Together, this body of work demonstrates how to elucidate a holistic understanding of the complex urban realities that Addis Ababa, and many other growing worldwide metropolises, face today and into the future.
Image associated with the article: New Healthy Settlements Responding to Pandemic Outbreaks: Approaches from (and for) the Global City
Article Open Access

New Healthy Settlements Responding to Pandemic Outbreaks: Approaches from (and for) the Global City

by Luca Maria Francesco Fabris, Federico Camerin, Gerardo Semprebon, Riccardo Maria Balzarotti pp. 385–406
The essay critically addresses several solutions and strategies for tackling urban inequalities to uphold the recent “right to the ‘healthy’ city” spatial paradigm based on early social science works by Emily Skinner and Jeffrey R. Masuda (2013) and then developed as a urban planning component by the interdisciplinary research group Barcelona Lab for Urban Environmental Justice and Sustainability (2019). The authors propose a transdisciplinary approach in dealing with city renewal-regeneration and the safer use of its spaces. The interrelation between urbanism and architecture, including environmental design, mobility, and social relations, among others, would merge to imagine a more ecologically and socially balanced urban milieu. The paper analyses four specific case studies assumed as proper approaches in dealing with the pandemic, critically reflecting on the application of “Superblocks,” “Tactical Urbanism,” and “15-minute City” concepts by illustrating and comparing their application in three global cities (respectively Barcelona, Beijing, and Milan). In a nutshell, the authors demonstrate that these policies have their crucial feature in being effective applications formulated for different contexts, proposing successful strategies to overcome health, environment, and mobility issues in all the contemporary global cities.
Image associated with the article: Imprints of an Invisible Virus: How Airborne Diseases Change Cities
Essay Open Access

Imprints of an Invisible Virus: How Airborne Diseases Change Cities

by Aki Ishida pp. 311–330
Once a clinical cure for COVID-19 is found, which infection prevention practices – both social and spatial – might remain, and what long-term impacts will they leave? This article examines the interrelationships between airborne diseases, social practices, and the design of physical and digital infrastructures for cities. Historically, infectious diseases have left long-term imprints on cities, from plumbing to hospitals. Spatial practices to prevent infection, such as clear physical barriers and car-free streets for socializing, must be implemented with a close examination of impacts on the mental, social wellbeing of both individuals and the broader community. Prevention practices examined include the use of transparent barriers that separate and connect people, the increased use of open windows, the adaptation of sidewalks and roads for physically distant socializing, and spatial negotiation and trust-building that occur in public spaces. As cities make design and policy changes to protect their citizens from the invisible virus, they must be mindful of the imprints the physical, social, and policy changes have on comprehensive wellness and equity for all people.
Editorial Editorial Open Access

In This Issue [1/2020]

by Maurizio Sabini pp. 5–7
Image associated with the article: Musings on Boredom, Midcentury Architecture, and Public Spaces
Essay Theory Open Access

Musings on Boredom, Midcentury Architecture, and Public Spaces

by Andreea Mihalache pp. 119–138
The rejection of “boredom” fueled the midcentury reaction against modernism, but little is known about the complicated presence of this mood in the architectural discourse. Far from being a mere rhetorical tool, the quip “Less is a bore” is part of Robert Venturi’s larger interest in boredom and was influenced by his reading of a book referenced repeatedly in Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture (1966): August Heckscher’s The Public Happiness (1962). A liberal writer and political activist, Heckscher situated boredom at the core of modern humanity’s alienation. While the concern with boredom was explicitly addressed in the humanities, I suggest that it was taking shape in midcentury architectural polemics under the influence of writings from other disciplines, as well as the emerging artistic practices that were deliberately embracing the “aesthetics of boredom.” Specifically, I will examine Venturi’s reading of Heckscher through two of his (unbuilt) civic projects that directly engage the issue of boredom: Three Buildings for a Town in Ohio (1965) and the entry for the Copley Square Competition (1966).   
Image associated with the article: Disaster Planning Across  Scales: Lessons from Post-Earthquake Rubble  Management in Oaxaca, Mexico
Article Sustainability Open Access

Disaster Planning Across Scales: Lessons from Post-Earthquake Rubble Management in Oaxaca, Mexico

by Dení López, Michael Hooper pp. 221–250
This paper examines rubble management as an important but often neglected component of disaster response and a powerful example of the frequent disconnect between national plans and local action. It focuses on five marginalized municipalities in Oaxaca, Mexico: Ciudad Ixtepec, Asuncion Ixtaltepec, El Espinal, Juchitan de Zaragoza, and Santa Maria Xadani. These constitute the region most affected by the Mexican earthquakes of September 2017, with roughly 58% of inhabitants suffering either partial or total loss of their houses. The paper builds on the results of fifty-one interviews, a cross-sectional survey with 384 residents, and a mapping analysis to reveal the challenges of post-disaster planning across scales. The results show that local perspectives were given little consideration in nationally-led rubble management plans, and that these documents were likely shaped by concerns over what constituted institutional legitimacy, rather than attention to local context. The paper concludes with a discussion of the findings through the lens of institutional isomorphism and offers recommendations for more effective post-disaster rubble management, particularly centered on increasing the involvement and capacity of residents, municipal governments, and other key institutions.
Image associated with the article: Waving the Magic Wand: An Argument for Reorganizing the Aridlands around Watersheds
Article Sustainability Open Access

Waving the Magic Wand: An Argument for Reorganizing the Aridlands around Watersheds

by Danika Cooper pp. 163–184
Irrigation remains the primary means of sustaining urbanization and stabilizing agricultural productivity in arid America. In the contest for the West, water is both wealth and power. Today’s struggle to overturn water scarcity is traceable through a long history of legislation overseeing land regulation, property speculation, societal development, and cultural attitudes, real and perceived, inscribed within the America’s aridlands. In reality, there is no magic wand - no miraculous technology - that alone will fulfill the needs of all who have been promised abundance in the aridlands. This paper proposes that revisiting John Wesley Powell’s 1893 proposal for aridland development in the context of today’s ecological conditions catalyzes an alternative response to today’s predictions of changing climates, and can provide the basis of an approach to the aridlands which builds from the enmeshed relationship between social and environmental systems. 
Image associated with the article: On the CIAM 7 Grid:  From an Ideological  to a Critical Tool
Essay Theory Open Access

On the CIAM 7 Grid: From an Ideological to a Critical Tool

by Pierre-Alain Croset, Andrea Canclini pp. 89–117
Much historiographical research has been produced on the post-war CIAMs, demonstrating the importance of the CIAM Grid, proposed as a “thinking tool” for representing the town planning projects at the CIAM 7 in Bergamo (1949). This essay proposes a new critical and epistemological examination of the CIAM Grid based on new archival documents and on a rereading of the exact words used by Le Corbusier, who proposed to consider the Grid as an “interlocutor.” Seventy years later, we propose to go beyond the failure of CIAM 7 and to elaborate a “new Grid,” with the name of “Second Life Grid,” as a critical tool for discussing exclusively projects related to the new paradigm of recycling and reusing buildings and urban spaces. Beginning with the question of the critical legacy of the CIAM Grid, our intention was to think of a Grid conceived no longer as an instrument of dogmatic and normative thought, but as an instrument of dialogical criticism which has been tested through an open call for projects and an international conference held in Bergamo in October, 2019.
Image associated with the article: American Mirror: the  Occupation of the ‘New World’ and the Rise of Architecture as We Know It
Essay Theory Open Access

American Mirror: the Occupation of the ‘New World’ and the Rise of Architecture as We Know It

by Fernando Luiz Lara pp. 71–88
This paper argues that the rise of architecture as a unique discipline and the conquest of the American continent are not just chronological coincidences but interdependent variables of the same process of modernization. Traditional scholarship in architecture has not entertained those parallel developments at all. The field of architectural history and theory still treats the spatial occupation of the Americas as a consequence of the Renaissance and European modernization, despite a few decades of scholarly literature in related disciplines questioning such assumptions. (Fanon 1961; Said 1978; Dussel 1980; Bhabha 1987;  Escobar 1994). Such scholarship demonstrates that the encounter of 1492 and the territorial occupation that followed played a central role in the development of Western culture in general, allowing the extrapolation of the same logic to the architectural discipline in particular. 
Image associated with the article: Aldo Rossi:  Representing Life
Book Review Criticism Open Access

Aldo Rossi: Representing Life

by Raffaella Neri pp. 253–259
 Aldo Rossi and the Spirit of ArchitectureBy Diane Y. F. GhirardoLondon: Yale University Press254 mm x 203 mm135 color + 5 b/w illustrations280 pagesUS$65 / £50.00 GBP (hardback)ISBN: 978-0300234930 
Image associated with the article: Giancarlo De Carlo. A Symposium
Conference Report Criticism Open Access

Giancarlo De Carlo. A Symposium

by Sara Marini, Marko Pogacnik pp. 261–278
Book Review Theory Open Access

Sibyl Moholy-Nagy: Architecture, Modernism and Its Discontents

by Eszter Polonyi pp. 513–518
 Sibyl Moholy-Nagy:Architecture, Modernismand Its Discontents By Hilde HeynenLondon: BloomsburyStudies in Modern Architecture, 2019234 mm x 156 mm 288 pagesUS$ 100.00 (hardback),US$ 31.46 (paperback)ISBN: 978-1-350094-11-6 
Image associated with the article: A New “Book of  the City of Ladies”
Book Review Urbanism Open Access

A New “Book of the City of Ladies”

by Dörte Kuhlmann, Guest-Editor, Alexia Bumbaris pp. 503–511
           Theoretikerinnen des Städtebaus.Texte und Projekte für die Stadt, By Katia Frey and Eliana Perotti (eds.)Berlin: Reimer, 2015240 mm x 170 mm42 b/w illustrations352 pages€ 49 (paperback)ISBN: 978-3-496-01532-1   Frauen blicken auf die Stadt. Architektinnen, Planerinnen, Reformerinnen. Theoretikerinnen des Städtebaus II, By Katia Frey and Eliana Perotti (eds.)Berlin: Reimer, 2019240 mm x 170 mm45 b/w illustrations360 pages€ 49 (paperback)ISBN: 978-3-496-01567-3
Image associated with the article: Women [Re]Build: Stories, Polemics, Futures
Book Review Criticism Open Access

Women [Re]Build: Stories, Polemics, Futures

by Lynnette Widder pp. 519–523
   Women [Re]Build: Stories, Polemics, Futures          By Franca Trubiano, Ramona Adlakha, and Ramune Bartuskaite (eds.)   Novato CA, USA: Applied Research and Design / Oro Editions, 2019, 2018241 mm x 165 mm144 pagesUS$ 29.95 (paperback)ISBN: 978-1-943532-43-8  
Image associated with the article: Beyond What Is Right
Editorial Editorial Open Access

Beyond What Is Right

by Maurizio Sabini pp. 269–271
Image associated with the article: Jiyūgaoka as Women’s Realm: A Case Study on Tokyo Genderfication
Article Open Access

Jiyūgaoka as Women’s Realm: A Case Study on Tokyo Genderfication

by Noemí Gómez Lobo, Yoshiharu Tsukamoto, Diego Martín Sánchez pp. 403–427
Framed within the question of how gender influences the production of urban space, this study reveals how Jiyūgaoka, a high-end suburban area in Tokyo, has developed by targeting a particular gender role: women as caretakers and consumers. Car-safe and bike-friendly, Jiyūgaoka pedestrian areas have more greenery, pavement, and urban furniture in comparison with the average Tokyo street. Jiyūgaoka spatial practices encourage the meeting of people in the public realm, creating relationships between behaviors and their supporting physical environment. By aiming at women, other non-normative bodies were rendered into the city, enhancing public life and creating an accessible milieu. Jiyūgaoka genderfication process, by which the overlaying of commercial and gender mechanisms has impacted urban phenomena, is shown through a chronological investigation of gender-charged contents and its mapping in the urban fabric. This study demonstrates how urban transformation in Jiyūgaoka has encompassed changes in the lives of women in Japanese society. Representative examples from each period illustrate the physical translation of this development, from a home cooking school to a promenade with hundreds of benches.
Editorial Editorial Open Access

In This Issue [1/2019]

by Maurizio Sabini pp. 5–6